|
|
|
|
|
Very clear and patient translation and commentary |
January 10, 2022 |
Reviewer:
Robert
|
|
This particular translation of Shantideva's classic text, together with the wonderful commentary by Padma Karpo and additional helpful notes for students and teachers by the translator himself, makes deep study of the bodhisatva path more possible. It is the first version of this text, for me, which has facilitated study and contemplation of the entire text, including the difficult chapter 9, the famous “wisdom†chapter. I had never thought to chant the text with others, but this presentation facilitates that as well, which can be a real help to study groups. For me, this time around, a number of obscurities were clarified, misconceptions were corrected, and parts of the text which I had no clue how to approach were made accessible through this very clear and patient translation and commentary.
This translation is unique in a number of ways, not the least of which is the inclusion of the great commentary by the Drukpa Kagyu master Padma Karpo. Previous translations of this text have relied on other sources, and Padma Karpo's offerings are especially rich and clear.
In translation work, the accurate meaning of words and their contexts is very important. Tony Duff makes a special point, not only in the accuracy of translation, but explaining the meaning of technical terms in a straightforward way, especially when they differ from previous translations. In general, translations of classic texts by Tony Duff are aimed at serious student-practitioners who are interested in accuracy, contemplation, practice and study. "Serious" does not necessarily mean experienced or well-read – just people who take care and interest in understanding and practicing with what they read. He does translate for a broader audience, of course, but he also translates for the sake of his students, which brings a special level of care and consideration to this work. This text has passed the test of being helpful to a number of his students with different capacities, experience, and levels of sophistication, and final revisions were made by Tony Duff in the context of actual feedback he was receiving from students studying with him.
Students who are interested in buddhadharma could do well to dip into this translation of this classic Indian text, as well as other translations by Tony Duff. He also offers classes from time to time using the texts he translates. It is rare to encounter study opportunities which are facilitated by someone which such depth of study, practice, and skill in teaching, and who himself encourages students to mix study with practice in the way that other authentic teachers do and have done in the past.
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|